Press and Journal

Switch to desktop Register Login

Payne: I resent insinuation that "pay-for-play occurred''


Middletown Borough Council appointed Mike Bowman to a First Ward vacancy on council on Tuesday, Jan. 20 – and some councilors cited a letter of support penned by state Rep. John D. Payne and sent to council as a factor in their decision. The Press And Journal asked Payne for comment afterward. This is the Jan. 22 letter he sent to the newspaper:



I am writing this letter in regards to the Jan. 20 Middletown Borough Council meeting. 


When I spoke to Mike Bowman, roughly between Christmas and New Year’s, he indicated there were only two candidates running for the First Ward position and one of the candidates did not live in the ward. Mike Bowman incidated to me he was going to get the appointment.


Therefore at his request, on Jan. 6 I wrote a letter on behalf of Mike Bowman for the vacant seat in the First Ward of Middletown Borough. I have enclosed a copy for your review. As you can see, nowhere in the letter did I use the words “highly recommend’’ or “recommend for the appointment to Middletown Borough Council.’’ I only suggested that Mike Bowman’s credentials be reviewed.


I am disappointed that, according to a recent news article, Chris McNamara took the opportunity to make this an issue and implied the reason why Middletown Borough Council appointed Mike Bowman was because I have secured in excess of $3 million in state funds for Middletown Borough. The inference is that I acquired the money in return for Mike Bowman’s appointment. I resent Chris McNamara insinuating a pay-for-play occurred.

Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, some of the funding I secured for Middletown Borough was before Chris McNamara was elected. The appointment should have been made on the merits of the candidates and not how much funding I was able to secure for Middletown Borough.


Regardless of who is on council, the board of supervisors or commissioners in any of the seven municipalities which I represent, I will continue to work to bring as many tax dollars as possible back to our district.


I have worked hard the past 12 years as your state representative to bring integrity and openness to my job. I have never missed a day of work or a vote on the House floor during these 12 years. For it to appear that I support one person’s views on the council over another’s is not true.


I don’t normally become involved in local issues or write letters to the media; however, I felt that due to Chris McNamara’s actions it was necessary to write this letter and set the record straight.

                                                                                         Rep. John D. Payne                

                                                                                         106th District



The Press And Journal asked Councilor Mike Bowman, Council President Chris McNamara and Chris Courogen, the borough's director of communications, if they wanted to respond to Payne’s letter. Courogen told the Press And Journal that he could not respond on behalf of McNamara regarding the issue. McNamara did not respond.


This is Bowman’s response:

 Bowman said he spoke to an assistant in Payne's Hershey office, but didn't speak personally to Payne until Jan. 7, a day after the date on the letter to council. Bowman said he told Payne's assistant that three people were in the running for the seat, not two.


 "I deny making those statements to John Payne, absolutely deny it. I didn't speak to him between Christmas and New Year's," Bowman said.


"I didn't need John's letter" to win the appointment, Bowman said. He said that his experience and background secured his appointment. "As far as my having the pull with John Payne to bring millions of dollars into Middletown, that is absurd," he said.






Jan. 22 letter from Rep. John Payne to The Press and Journal




Last Updated on Thursday, 29 January 2015 16:43

Hits: 26

Readers' Views: Vague, inaccurate statements about police force


Click here to view David Rhen's letter to Middletown voters.




Please print this letter in time to get to the voters of Middletown Borough.


It seems that members of the current Borough Council like to make statements at the 11th hour that are either vague or factually inaccurate. Here are a few examples:


• Dave Rhen, chairman of council's Public Safety Committee, recently mailed a letter through out the borough. In one statement, Rhen says, “I know all too well the problems associated with the Borough's Police Force.”  Rhen held hearings in 2011 dealing with police corruption. The only people speaking to police wrongdoing were those who had been arrested by the police. The media covered those hearings but nothing was ever reported on the news. Dave Rhen and crew went to the District Attorney and Attorney General with their tales of corruption. They were told that there was nothing criminal going on. Rhen is the one who has given our Police Department a black eye with his unfounded accusations of corruption. He even urged more civil law suits against the Borough. Has Middletown been sued more than other police departments?


• Rhen's statement that the police force was “Virtually unmanaged for most of the past two decades.” Rhen was on council three different times – 1984, 2001 and 2010. So Rhen has been on council for at least 12 years while all this so-called mismanagement was happening – and as chairman of the Public Safety Committee, what did he do to correct it?


• Let's talk about police overtime. Again I quote Rhen, who said police “have cost the taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars in unbudgeted overtime expenses.” You slashed a budget item to an unrealistically low amount, then say it is the police force's fault that overtime is over budget. If overtime is truly over budget by hundreds of thousands of dollars, then it is poor budgeting on the part of the Borough Manager and Borough Council.  Several police officers have retired/resigned and the positions have not been filled. So there are less officers to fill the same number of shifts, making the only alternative overtime. The national average is 2.3 full time officers per 1,000 residents. Middletown has 13 full time officers for just over 9,000 residents – 2.3 x 9 = 20.7.  How safe do you feel?


• Rhen states, “Borough Council has been taking major steps to modernize and professionalize the Police Department.” What steps, and how much did it cost? Remember, this council says the borough's broke.


• Rhen states, “Police dispatch has been moved to Dauphin County's 911 system, which will hold officers more accountable for their whereabouts and actions.” The dissolution of our dispatch center is the reason that none of us can contact the police officers or get copies of reports. County 911 has no control over our police officers and does nothing to hold them accountable – they only dispatch the calls.


This council has appointed three police chiefs in the last two years. I certainly hope they get it right soon. How much did they spend to buy each of those chiefs out of their contract?


How much will the quest for accreditation cost us taxpayers?


Rhen states, “Excess overtime has been curbed.” Do you notice that dollar amounts are never quoted. If they saved us so much money why not tell us how much?


 • Now, Bob Givler's $63,000 payout: If Mr. Givler was dedicated enough that he didn't use the leave available to him, then he was entitled to get paid for it when he retired. Unlike police chiefs who get their contract bought out when we want them to move on.


Do you see how easy it is to be mislead by vague statements? They make statements without backing them up with any facts.


What axes do these people have to grind with our Police Department? Is it that several of them or their family members have been arrested?


Let me tell you something about our police department. In a 2010/2011 study done regarding the Communications Center the statistics showed our Police Department made more criminal arrests than departments more than twice our size. The study was made part of the public record and previously listed on the borough's website.


I'm not sure why our candidates have not asked this question: How could this council take us from a surplus of funds to financially distressed in less than two years?


Dave Rhen was sure willing to make accusations about Bob Givler but doesn't say what Mr. Curry is going to do or what he is about, other than he has no ties to the Police Department.  What does Mr. Curry know about running or overseeing a police department?


Mary L. Hiester



(The writer is a former president of Middletown Borough Council.)



Last Updated on Tuesday, 29 October 2013 19:00

Hits: 749

Readers' Views: God made creatures on 2 days



For those who might remember, I wrote a letter years ago challenging another letter writer, Herbert C. Moore, to give me an example of one species evolving into a higher species. I waited, and was interested to see his example. There was no example.
I still haven’t seen any evidence from Moore in any of his recent responses to my recent letter (“Evolution is a fairy tale for adults,’’ Feb. 13 Viewpoints).

Last Updated on Tuesday, 26 March 2013 16:22

Hits: 2603

Halloween blurb was boo-tiful


I’m writing to thank you for publishing my little press release (and photo) about the ladies at The Essex House and their Halloween party.


Last Updated on Tuesday, 27 November 2012 14:06

Hits: 2077

Readers' Views: In Middletown's heyday, we had plenty of money



When I first took office on Middletown Borough Council I was quite impressed. Middletown was so well off financially that they allowed the Middletown Area School District to keep the entire 2 percent of the local earned income tax. It was designed to give 1 percent to the school district and 1 percent to the municipality.

Last Updated on Tuesday, 27 November 2012 13:59

Hits: 2818